Hospice care serves as a unique specialty of nursing by focusing on providing comfort and support to patients nearing the end of their lives. While deeply fulfilling, this field presents nurses with an array of ethical dilemmas that require thoughtful consideration and empathy.
In this article, we will explore the 7 ethical dilemmas in hospice care and discuss effective strategies for managing them.
Truth-Telling and Patient Autonomy
In healthcare ethics, one of the fundamental principles is respecting patient autonomy. However, the dilemma of truth-telling often arises in hospice care. The question of how much to disclose to patients about their prognosis, especially when they prefer not to know, presents a delicate balancing act.
Nurses working in hospice care must establish open lines of communication with patients and their families, allowing them to express their preferences regarding the disclosure of information. Honesty, sensitivity, and empathy are vital components in addressing this ethical dilemma.
Palliative sedation involves administering sedative medications to relieve severe suffering in terminally sick patients, even if it might accelerate their death. This practice raises ethical questions about the balance between alleviating suffering and preserving the divinity of life.
Nurses play a pivotal role in advocating for ethical guidelines and ensuring that palliative sedation is done only as a last resort when all other options for symptom management have been exhausted. Nurses play a vital role in helping patients and their families make informed decisions by discussing options for end-of-life care.
Withholding or Withdrawing Treatment
Healthcare providers may face decisions regarding the withholding or withdrawal of treatment, including artificial nutrition and hydration. Striking a balance between the principle of non-maleficence (do no harm) and the patient’s best interests can be a challenging task.
Nurses should engage in ethical discussions with the healthcare team, patients, and their families to determine the most appropriate course of action, with a primary focus on the patient’s comfort and quality of life.
[Editor’s Notes: Just for clarification: To enter hospice care, the patient has to agree to end all curative care and treatment options for the terminal illness and opt for comfort care and symptom management. That does not mean that if the patient develops pneumonia or a UTI or breaks a hip for instance, it would not be treated. Hospice formulary antibiotics can be used in hospice. If hospitalization is required, the patient can opt to revoke hospice, be treated, and then resume hospice care afterwards. The patient also retains the right to revoke hospice care at any time. Artificial nutrition and hydration usually cause more suffering than they alleviate for the patient and are not recommended at End of Life. ]
Cultural and Spiritual Sensitivity
Hospice care frequently brings together individuals from diverse cultural and religious backgrounds. Nurses must navigate the ethical dilemma of respecting patients’ cultural and spiritual beliefs while providing the best possible care.
This may entail accommodating dietary restrictions, facilitating religious rituals, and offering spiritual support. Developing cultural competence and a profound understanding of various belief systems is crucial in addressing these ethical challenges.
Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide
Euthanasia and assisted suicide remain contentious topics within healthcare. While Euthanasia is illegal in 50 states, there are 10 jurisdictions that legalize physician-assisted suicide.
In the context of hospice care, the ethical dilemma concerning these issues is particularly sensitive. Some patients may express a desire to hasten their death, while others may request assistance in doing so.
Nurses must follow the protocols to legal and ethical guidelines in their jurisdiction, which may prohibit any form of active euthanasia or assisted suicide. Nonetheless, they must continue to provide emotional support and pain management to patients who are suffering.
[Editor’s Notes: Please note that Medicare has specific rules regarding this subject and state laws can vary and may be updated frequently as this issue evolves. Please always consult your hospice, intermediary and state BON for specifics and guidelines.]
Hospice care often operates with limited budgets and constrained resources. Nurses may encounter ethical dilemmas when allocating resources, such as medications, equipment, or staff time.
The challenge lies in delivering the best possible care within these constraints. Nurses should advocate for their patients, aiming to balance resource allocation while prioritizing patient comfort and dignity.
Family Conflict and Decision-Making
Family dynamics can give rise to ethical challenges in the hospice care setting. Disagreements among family members regarding a patient’s care can lead to emotional turmoil and potentially compromise the patient’s well-being.
Nurses can play a vital role in mediating these conflicts, ensuring that the patient’s best interests remain the primary focus. Encouraging open communication, empathy, and ethical decision-making can help resolve these dilemmas.
Hospice care is a unique specialty where compassion and ethical decision-making are practiced.
As nurses, we must be prepared to confront these ethical dilemmas, providing care that respects patient autonomy, preserves their dignity, and ensures their comfort. Open communication, empathy, and a commitment to the principles of healthcare ethics serve as our guiding lights in navigating these complex issues.
While the dilemmas encountered in hospice care may be challenging, some situations allow opportunities for nurses to make a profound difference in the lives of their patients during end-of-life.
By addressing these 7 ethical dilemmas with sensitivity and professionalism, nurses can provide the highest standard of care and support to those who need it most.
Nelson is an O.R. nurse with a passion for healthcare. His blog, nelsonrmarquez.com shares his firsthand knowledge and experience from eight years working as a nurse. Whether he’s sharing stories from the O.R. or offering advice to aspiring nurses, his articles are sure to resonate with his readers.
Join Nelson on his journey as he shares the highs, lows, and everything in between in the life of a nurse. Prepare to be inspired as you gain the unwavering commitment and spirit that define the nursing profession.
OCT. 25-28 only
30% off BEYOND SCRUBS! HTTPS://SCRUBSANDBEYOND.SJV.IO/C/2309045/1822218/7589